Skip to content

Tapped for mana events should still fire when no mana produced#15411

Open
matoro wants to merge 1 commit into
magefree:masterfrom
matoro:fertileground
Open

Tapped for mana events should still fire when no mana produced#15411
matoro wants to merge 1 commit into
magefree:masterfrom
matoro:fertileground

Conversation

@matoro

@matoro matoro commented Jun 20, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor

605.2. A mana ability remains a mana ability even if the game state doesn’t allow it to produce mana.
Example: A permanent has an ability that reads “{T}: Add {G} for each creature you control.” The ability is still a mana ability even if you control no creatures or if the permanent is already tapped.

https://www.tumblr.com/magicjudge/71264631258/if-i-have-a-gaeas-cradle-enchanted-with-wild

If I have a Gaea's Cradle enchanted with Wild Growth, and no creatures in play, can I tap it for {G}?
Yes. Gaea's Cradle always has a mana ability, even if you have no creatures.

Fixes #15362

I believe that since ManaOptions uses different logic, this won't take the potential mana you could make into account when highlighting cards as playable/not playable, but you can at least manually activate it and pay from floating.

> 605.2. A mana ability remains a mana ability even if the game state doesn’t allow it to produce mana.
> Example: A permanent has an ability that reads “{T}: Add {G} for each creature you control.” The ability is still a mana ability even if you control no creatures or if the permanent is already tapped.

https://www.tumblr.com/magicjudge/71264631258/if-i-have-a-gaeas-cradle-enchanted-with-wild

> If I have a Gaea's Cradle enchanted with Wild Growth, and no creatures in play, can I tap it for {G}?
> Yes. Gaea's Cradle always has a mana ability, even if you have no creatures.

Fixes magefree#15362

I believe that since `ManaOptions` uses different logic, this won't take
the potential mana you could make into account when highlighting cards
as playable/not playable, but you can at least manually activate it and
pay from floating.
@matoro

matoro commented Jun 21, 2026

Copy link
Copy Markdown
Contributor Author

Btw, I think this directly conflicts with this ruling on [[City of Shadows]]

You can activate City of Shadows's second ability while it has no storage counters on it, though it won't add any mana in this case. You did not tap it for mana, though, in case any abilities (such as the ability of a Fertile Ground enchanting it) care about that.

@github-actions

Copy link
Copy Markdown

City of Shadows - (Gatherer) (Scryfall) (EDHREC)

Land
{T}, Exile a creature you control: Put a storage counter on this land.
{T}: Add {C} for each storage counter on this land.

Sign up for free to join this conversation on GitHub. Already have an account? Sign in to comment

Projects

None yet

Development

Successfully merging this pull request may close these issues.

Gaea's Cradle not triggering Fertile Ground

1 participant